Aliases
Aliases
Admin path: Email Server > Aliases (view_mailbox_aliases.cfm,
inc/add_mailbox_alias_action.cfm, inc/edit_mailbox_alias_action.cfm,
inc/delete_mailbox_alias_action.cfm, inc/get_mailbox_alias_json.cfm).
This page manages alternate email addresses for local mailboxes on
the Email Server topology. Each row in the mailbox_aliases table maps
one inbound address (e.g., sales@company.com) to one destination, or
to Postfix's discard transport for silent disposal.
An alias may have several destinations, one row each, in which case Postfix concatenates them into a single recipient list and one inbound message fans out to all of them. That is what a distribution list is here: an alias with more than one destination, not a separate concept with its own page. Destinations do not have to be local mailboxes; any valid address is accepted, including addresses outside your own domains, with the forwarding caveats described under External destinations.
Aliases have no SMTP authentication, no IMAP/POP3 access, and no password of their own. They are rewrite rules consumed by Postfix.
Two capabilities that used to live on this page have moved:
- Send-As is granted per mailbox, under Mailboxes > Actions > Send As. See Send-As moved to the mailbox.
- Adding destinations to an existing alias happens in the Edit modal. Add creates an alias and refuses an address that already exists.
Not the same as Virtual Recipients
Email Server aliases and Email Relay virtual recipients share the same underlying Postfix lookup but enforce different topology rules. See Virtual Recipients for the full distinction; the short version:
| Mailbox Aliases (this page) | Virtual Recipients | |
|---|---|---|
| Table | mailbox_aliases |
virtual_recipients |
| Domain type | Mailbox domains (domains.type = 'mailbox') |
Relay domains (domains.type = 'relay' or NULL) |
| Delivery target | Anywhere: a local Dovecot mailbox, any other address, or discard:silently |
Anywhere, internal or external |
| Several destinations | Yes, one row each | Yes, one row each |
| UNIQUE constraint | uq_alias_dest on the (alias_address, delivers_to) pair |
None; the console is the guard |
Reachable By (internal_only) |
Supported | Not supported, and deliberately so |
| Send-As | Granted per mailbox, not here | Vestigial schema flag, nothing reads it |
Catch-all (@domain) |
Not supported | Supported |
| Discard transport | Supported (silent drop) | Not supported |
| Typical use | support@company.com → alice@company.com (both local) |
info@company.com → admin@externalpartner.example |
Both tables feed the same virtual_alias_maps lookup via a single
UNION query in mysql-virtual.cf:
SELECT maps FROM virtual_recipients WHERE virtual_address = '%s'
UNION
SELECT delivers_to FROM mailbox_aliases WHERE alias_address = '%s'
The add handlers in each page enforce the topology gate: trying to create a mailbox alias for a relay domain is rejected with error 12, and the Virtual Recipients add handler rejects mailbox-domain rows with a pointer back to this page.
Storage and lookup path
The order here is not the obvious one. main.cf sets
receive_override_options = no_address_mappings globally, which disables
virtual alias expansion in the cleanup that runs for mail arriving on port
25. The map is still consulted at smtpd to decide whether the recipient
exists, but the rewrite is deferred until after content filtering, at
the :10026 reinjection listener which overrides that setting.
inbound SMTP (port 25) ──► hermes_postfix_dkim
│
│ smtpd: helo, sender, recipient checks
│ recipient VALIDATED against
│ virtual_alias_maps
│ ◄── mysql:/etc/postfix/mysql-virtual.cf
│ │
│ ▼
│ ┌──────────────────────────────────┐
│ │ hermes_db_server │
│ │ UNION across virtual_recipients │
│ │ and mailbox_aliases │
│ └──────────────────────────────────┘
│
│ check_recipient_access on the
│ internal-only map may REJECT here
│
│ cleanup runs with no_address_mappings,
│ so the recipient is NOT rewritten yet
▼
amavis (10021), then hermes_ciphermail
│
▼
reinjection on :10026, which DOES
expand virtual_alias_maps
│
▼
rewritten recipient(s), one per row
│
┌───────────────┴────────────────┐
│ │
forward (delivers_to = discard (delivers_to =
one or more destinations) 'discard:silently')
│ │
▼ ▼
LMTP → hermes_dovecot discard(8) transport
for local destinations, │
onward SMTP for external ▼
message silently dropped
no bounce, no DSN, no log entry
beyond the queue acceptance
The MySQL lookup is live: adding a row in this page takes effect on
the next inbound message, with no Postfix reload, no postmap, and
no template regeneration.
Reachable By reaches main.cf differently. The check_recipient_access
map that enforces it is named in smtpd_recipient_restrictions, and that
directive is not copied from main.cf.HERMES on a running system:
generate_postfix_configuration.cfm rebuilds it from the parameters
table, concatenating every child = '1' row whose parent_name is
smtpd_recipient_restrictions, ordered by order1. The map is a seeded
row there at order1 1.150, so it appears whenever that directive is
regenerated, which the upgrade does for you and any Postfix settings save
does thereafter.
The mailbox_aliases table
| Column | Type | Role |
|---|---|---|
id |
INT PK | Surrogate key |
alias_address |
VARCHAR(255) | The address being rewritten. Full email only, no catch-all syntax. Indexed by idx_alias_address, which is what Postfix looks it up by. Repeats across rows when an alias has several destinations. |
delivers_to |
VARCHAR(255) | One destination. For alias_type = 'forward' this is any valid address, local or external; for alias_type = 'discard' it is hardcoded to the literal string discard:silently, which Postfix routes through the discard(8) transport. |
alias_type |
VARCHAR(20) | forward (default) or discard. Belongs to the address, so every row for one alias carries the same value. |
internal_only |
TINYINT(3) | 1 if only senders inside your own domains may mail this address. Also a property of the address, written across every row for it. Defaults to 0. |
send_as |
TINYINT(3) | Vestigial. Nothing reads it. Send-As is granted per mailbox now. The column is still written on insert so existing rows keep their value; dropping it is a later cleanup with no urgency. |
domain_id |
INT | FK to domains.id; set on insert from the parsed domain part of alias_address. Used to filter the page by domain and to enforce the mailbox-topology gate. |
created_at |
DATETIME | Audit timestamp. Survives an edit on rows that did not change, because the save is a diff rather than a rewrite. |
Why the UNIQUE key changed
Until v260815, uq_alias_address made alias_address unique, which
pinned an alias to exactly one row and therefore one destination.
Dropping that key is what allows several destinations, and it is the only
schema change the feature needed.
It was also the index Postfix used for every lookup, since
mysql-virtual.cf queries WHERE alias_address = '%s' on each message.
Dropping it without a replacement would have turned every alias lookup
into a full table scan, so idx_alias_address took its place.
The rule that replaced "one row per address" is "no exact duplicate
pair", enforced by uq_alias_dest on (alias_address, delivers_to).
Existing data satisfied it by construction, since alias_address was
unique until the moment the key was dropped.
Note that the equivalent key was deliberately not added to
virtual_recipients. Existing installs may already hold exact duplicates
there, and ADD UNIQUE would abort the whole schema upgrade on the first
one it met.
The two alias types
Forward
Delivers mail to one or more destinations. The Delivers To picker is
populated from the live mailbox list (mailbox_type = 'user') so a real
target can be chosen from a list, but any valid address can be typed in
instead.
sales@company.com → alice@company.com
support@company.com → helpdesk@company.com, alice@company.com,
oncall@partner.example
The alias address must be on a mailbox domain that this server hosts. Destinations have no such restriction: cross-domain and external destinations are both allowed.
The old requirement that every destination already exist in the
mailboxes table (error 16) is gone. It made external forwarding
impossible on mailbox domains while relay domains allowed it freely,
which was an inconsistency rather than a policy.
Distribution lists
A distribution list is an alias with more than one destination. There is no separate page, no separate table, and no separate concept to learn.
Add accepts several destinations at once; Edit shows the whole set as removable chips and diffs the save. The table groups by address, so a twenty-member list is one row with twenty chips rather than twenty near-identical lines.
Consider setting Reachable By to internal-only on any list with external destinations. Without it, one message from anyone on the internet becomes twenty outbound messages relayed by this gateway.
External destinations
Any valid address is accepted as a destination, and external ones are badged wherever they appear, both in the table and in the Add and Edit modals. The badge is deliberate: the person auditing an alias in six months is not the person who created it.
The caveats are real and worth stating to whoever asks for the forward:
- Forwarded mail leaves with the original sender's address, so SPF fails at the receiving end.
- If the message was modified on the way through, by an External Banner or LinkGuard for instance, the original DKIM signature no longer validates either.
- Senders whose domain publishes a strict DMARC policy can therefore have mail to those destinations rejected.
Local destinations are unaffected by all three.
Reachable By (internal-only addresses)
Controls who may send to an address, which is a different question
from where that address delivers. Anyone is the default and matches the
behaviour every alias had before v260815. Only senders in your own domains rejects mail from outside.
Enforced by a check_recipient_access mysql: map in
smtpd_recipient_restrictions, following the discard-recipients map
already in that chain. permit_mynetworks short-circuits ahead of it, so
anything reaching the map arrived from outside and a plain REJECT is
correct. No sender-domain test is used, because trusting an
unauthenticated claim to be from your own domain would be worse than
useless on a gateway.
The map uses SELECT DISTINCT. A twenty-member alias matches twenty rows,
and without it Postfix would concatenate twenty REJECT strings into one
malformed action.
Two limits worth knowing:
- Catch-alls cannot be internal-only. Postfix probes access maps by bare domain, and this page does not support catch-all syntax anyway.
- Relay domains do not have this setting at all, deliberately. A relay domain exists so the internet can send to it, and the customer's own users never traverse this gateway for same-domain mail because their server is authoritative and resolves it locally. Internal-only there would reject the only traffic that arrives and permit traffic that never does.
Discard
Silently drops all mail with no bounce, no DSN, and no error returned
to the sender. The handler hardcodes delivers_to = 'discard:silently',
which Postfix interprets as the discard(8) transport with the literal
nexthop silently. Useful for addresses like noreply@ or
donotreply@ where bounces would invite spam-mining attempts.
noreply@company.com → discarded
donotreply@company.com → discarded
unsubscribe@company.com → discarded
Operational consequence. Discard is irrecoverable — there is no queue entry, no quarantine, no recovery. The message is accepted by Postfix and immediately dropped. Use discard for addresses that should never receive replies; do not use it as a quiet alternative to bouncing mail you actually want to reject (use Postfix recipient restrictions for that).
Fields on the page
Add Alias modal
| Field | Notes |
|---|---|
| Alias Address | Full email. Must validate as an email, must be on a mailbox domain (domains.type = 'mailbox'), and must not already exist as a mailbox, an alias, or a virtual recipient. Conflicts produce errors 13 / 14 / 17, and a non-mailbox domain produces 12. |
| Type | Forward (deliver to mailbox) (default) or Discard (silently drop all mail). JS toggles the Delivers To field based on selection. |
| Delivers To | Tom Select chips, one or more. The option list comes from mailboxes WHERE mailbox_type = 'user', so clicking the field offers real targets, and any other address can be typed and accepted on Enter. Splits on comma, semicolon, whitespace and newline so a pasted list works. One row is written per chip. Required for forward, ignored for discard. |
| Reachable By | Anyone (default) or Only senders in your own domains. See Reachable By. |
Add creates. An alias address that already exists is refused with error 14, pointing at that row's Edit button. Routing both operations through Add gave two ways to do one thing and produced an answer nobody could act on: submitting an existing address whose destinations were all already stored could only report that nothing had changed.
Aliases table
DataTables surface: searchable, sortable, paginated, stateSave: true.
Rows are grouped by address, so an alias with twenty destinations is
one row with twenty chips.
| Column | Source |
|---|---|
| Actions | Edit and Delete, both operating on the whole alias |
| Alias | mailbox_aliases.alias_address |
| Domain | domains.domain (joined via domain_id) |
| Type | Badge, Forward (blue) or Discard (dark), plus a count badge when there is more than one destination |
| Delivers To | Display-only chips, one per destination, external ones badged |
| Reachable By | Badge, Internal only or Open. Read with MAX(internal_only) so a mixed state, which should not arise, reads as restricted rather than open |
A Domain filter dropdown above the table narrows the visible rows to a single mailbox domain. The dropdown only lists domains that currently have at least one alias.
Note for anyone changing this table: order and columnDefs are
index-based and stateSave persists the sort by index, so inserting or
removing a column means updating both.
Edit modal
Owns the alias's whole destination set. The modal shows every destination as a removable chip and submits the set you want to end up with, so the save is a diff: insert what is new, delete what was taken off, leave the rest untouched.
Diffing rather than delete-then-reinsert matters for three reasons. There
is never a moment when the alias has no destinations and mail would
bounce, created_at survives on members that did not change, and a
failure partway through cannot leave the alias empty.
Adding and removing destinations happens here and only here.
The address is read-only after creation, so an edit can never split a
grouped alias by renaming one row out of it. Type belongs to the address:
converting to Discard deletes every real destination and replaces them
with the single pseudo-destination, which cannot be done with an UPDATE
because setting them all to discard:silently would collide with
uq_alias_dest as soon as there was more than one row. The page warns
before a conversion discards a multi-destination list.
send_as is deliberately not written by this handler. Its control is
gone from the modal, so a cfparam default of 0 would silently zero the
column on every edit.
Delete
Per-row delete with a confirmation modal, naming the alias and its
destination count. Removes every row for the address, plus any
sender_login_maps entries for it. Because aliases don't own a Maildir or
any on-disk state, deletion is instant and reversible only by re-creating
the alias.
Send-As moved to the mailbox
Send-As is granted under Mailboxes > Actions > Send As, not on this page. There is no Send-As control in the Add or Edit modal.
Why it moved. A single Yes/No toggle on an alias worked while an alias
had exactly one destination. It stopped making sense the moment an alias
could have twenty, because one toggle would have granted send-as to every
member of a list at once, with no way to say "these three may, the other
seventeen may not". Membership and identity are separate questions.
sender_login_maps now has exactly one writer.
The grant itself is unchanged. Selecting an alias for a mailbox inserts:
INSERT IGNORE INTO sender_login_maps (sender, login_user)
VALUES ('sales@company.com', 'alice@company.com');
That row participates in Postfix's smtpd_sender_login_maps lookup
on the submission port. The effect: when alice@company.com authenticates
to Submission (587) and tries to send a message with From: sales@company.com, Postfix accepts the From: because the
(sender, login_user) pair exists in the map. Without Send-As,
Postfix's reject_sender_login_mismatch would reject the submission
because alice@ is not the canonical owner of sales@.
This makes Send-As a true alternate-identity grant, not just a "vanity From:".
Granting is necessary but not sufficient
The grant alone changes nothing the user can see. No mail protocol exposes send-as permissions to a client, so the user must also add the address as an identity in whatever they read mail with. Until they do, the From: field stays a plain label and the alias is nowhere to be found.
This is the single most common support question after a grant, and it looks exactly like the grant not working:
| Client | Where the user adds it |
|---|---|
| Webmail (Nextcloud Mail) | Mail > Account settings > Aliases > Add alias |
| Thunderbird | Account Settings > Manage Identities > Add |
| Outlook | Account Settings, additional email addresses |
| Apple Mail | Account settings, Edit Email Addresses |
In every case the From: field only becomes a dropdown once the account has more than one identity.
Worth knowing about the failure mode in the other direction: a user can
add an identity for an address they have not been granted. The client
accepts it happily and Postfix refuses the message at submission with
Sender address rejected: not owned by user .... That is
reject_sender_login_mismatch doing its job, and it is also a clean way
to verify the grant is genuinely being enforced rather than submission
being open to any From: address.
The user-facing version of this is in Set Up Your Devices, under "Sending from an alias".
Grants are scoped to aliases on the mailbox's own domain, re-derived server-side rather than trusted from the form.
Consequence worth knowing: changing an alias's destination no longer moves the send-as grant with it. That is intentional. The grant says "this mailbox may send from this address", which has nothing to do with where the address happens to deliver, so silently transferring it on a destination change would be wrong. Deleting the alias still revokes the grant.
Conflict checks at insert time
The add handler runs four duplicate checks before the INSERT:
| Check | Error | What it prevents |
|---|---|---|
mailboxes WHERE username = alias_address |
13 | Alias collides with an actual mailbox. The mailbox itself would always win the lookup, so the alias would be dead weight. |
mailbox_aliases WHERE alias_address = alias_address |
14 | The alias already exists. Add creates; changing an existing alias, including adding and removing destinations, is the Edit modal's job, and the message says so. Note the database no longer backs this check: v260815 dropped the UNIQUE key on alias_address (that is what allows several destinations) and replaced it with uq_alias_dest on the (alias_address, delivers_to) pair, so this handler check is the only thing preventing a second alias row for an address that already has one. |
virtual_recipients WHERE virtual_address = alias_address |
17 | Alias collides with a relay-topology virtual recipient. The UNION lookup would return both rows and the resulting fan-out is almost never the intent — the error tells the admin to remove the relay-side row first. |
domains WHERE domain = X AND type = 'mailbox' |
12 | Alias's domain isn't on the mailbox-topology side. Use Virtual Recipients for relay domains. |
All four checks are advisory in the UI sense but enforced server-side so a forged form post can't bypass them.
Domain-delete dependency
There is no explicit dependency check on mailbox-domain deletion for
aliases — but mailbox domains are typically not removed unless every
mailbox under them is also being removed, and the alias rows become
orphaned (domain_id no longer resolves) rather than actively
harmful. Stale mailbox_aliases rows whose domain_id no longer
exists are skipped by the page query because of the
INNER JOIN domains ... AND d.type = 'mailbox'. Operational best
practice: delete aliases first, then mailboxes, then the domain.
Failure semantics
| What breaks | What happens |
|---|---|
| Blank alias address in Add | error 10 banner, no DB write |
| Invalid email format | error 11 |
Domain not in domains or not mailbox-type |
error 12 |
| Address already exists as a mailbox | error 13 |
| Address already exists as an alias | error 14 |
| Address already exists as a virtual recipient | error 17 |
| Forward type with blank Delivers To, or a list that deduplicates to nothing | error 15 |
| Any destination is not a valid email address | error 16. Fails the whole submission on the first bad entry rather than silently dropping it and reporting partial success. No longer means "target mailbox doesn't exist"; external destinations are allowed |
| Edit with missing alias_id | error 20 |
| Edit / delete with stale alias_id | error 21 |
MySQL hermes_db_server down |
Postfix virtual_alias_maps lookups fail. Default behavior is to defer affected mail with a temporary error and retry — legitimate mail is held, not bounced. |
Files and containers touched
| Path | Owner | Role |
|---|---|---|
config/hermes/var/www/html/admin/2/view_mailbox_aliases.cfm |
hermes_commandbox |
Page + table + Add / Edit / Delete modals |
config/hermes/var/www/html/admin/2/inc/add_mailbox_alias_action.cfm |
hermes_commandbox |
Add handler with the four-way conflict check; writes one row per destination |
config/hermes/var/www/html/admin/2/inc/edit_mailbox_alias_action.cfm |
hermes_commandbox |
Edit handler; diffs the submitted destination set against what is stored |
config/hermes/var/www/html/admin/2/inc/delete_mailbox_alias_action.cfm |
hermes_commandbox |
Delete handler; removes every row for the address plus any send-as map entry |
config/hermes/var/www/html/admin/2/inc/get_mailbox_alias_json.cfm |
hermes_commandbox |
AJAX endpoint that hydrates the Edit modal with the whole destination set |
config/hermes/var/www/html/admin/2/inc/edit_mailbox_send_as_action.cfm |
hermes_commandbox |
The only writer of sender_login_maps. Reached from the Mailboxes page |
config/hermes/var/www/html/admin/2/inc/get_mailbox_send_as_json.cfm |
hermes_commandbox |
AJAX endpoint listing aliases on the mailbox's own domain |
/etc/postfix/mysql-virtual.cf |
hermes_postfix_dkim (volume-mounted) |
The UNION lookup definition shared with virtual_recipients |
/etc/postfix/mysql-internal-only-recipients.cf |
hermes_postfix_dkim (volume-mounted) |
The check_recipient_access map behind Reachable By. Uses SELECT DISTINCT |
mailbox_aliases, sender_login_maps, mailboxes, domains, virtual_recipients |
hermes_db_server |
Storage and conflict-detection tables |
Nothing on this page shells out to Postfix — no postmap, no
postfix reload, no template regeneration. The MySQL lookup picks up
new rows on the next inbound message.
Related
- Email Relay > Virtual Recipients: the relay-topology equivalent. Pick the page by the alias address's own domain, not by the destination. Both pages now support external destinations and fan-out to several destinations, so those are no longer the deciding factor. Relay domains additionally support catch-alls; mailbox domains additionally support Reachable By and the discard transport.
- Domains — the mailbox-domain list this page filters
against. An alias's domain must exist there with
type = 'mailbox'. - Mailboxes — the destination mailbox list. The Delivers To dropdown is populated from active user mailboxes.
- Shared Mailboxes: when several users need to read the same incoming mail, use a shared mailbox rather than an alias. The distinction is one copy or many. A shared mailbox is a single inbox several people open, so a message read by one is read by all and replies come from a common address. A distribution list delivers a separate copy into each member's own mailbox, and each acts on it independently.
- Mailbox Rules — Sieve-based filtering that runs on the destination mailbox after alias rewrite. Aliases route mail to a mailbox; Sieve rules then sort it within that mailbox.
- Settings — the global Email Server toggles. Aliases work regardless of the Mailbox Sharing master switch — they have no Dovecot-side configuration to be gated on.
- Authentication Settings — Submission-port authentication that the Send-As flag piggybacks on. A user must be able to authenticate to Submission as their primary address before Send-As lets them switch identities.